in

Detritivore conversion of litter into faeces accelerates organic matter turnover

Detritivore and leaf litter collection

We collected six phylogenetically diverse species of detritivores in various areas of the Scottish Lowlands in May and June 2018, including three millipede species (Diplopoda), two woodlouse species (Crustacea) and one snail species (Gastropoda). Millipede species include the common pill millipede (Glomeris marginata (Villers, 1789)) collected near Peebles, UK (55°38′45.8″N, 3°07′55.4″W), the striped millipede (Ommatoiulus sabulosus (Linnaeus, 1758)) collected near Dunfermline, UK (56°02′23.7″N, 3°19′49.2″W) and the white-legged millipede (Tachypodoiulus niger (Leach, 1815)) collected near Dundee, UK (56°32′08.5″N, 3°01′51.9″W). Woodlouse species include the common pill woodlouse (Armadillidium vulgare (Latreille, 1804)) collected near Dunfermline, UK (56°01′35.3″N 3°23′14.1″W) and the common rough woodlouse (Porcellio scaber (Latreille, 1804) collected in Stirling, UK (56°07′26.7″N, 3°55′51.2″W). The snail species was the brown-lipped snail (Cepaea nemoralis (Linnaeus, 1758)) collected in Stirling, UK (56°08′07.3″N, 3°55′16.3″W). These species are common in diverse ecosystems across Mediterranean and temperate ecosystems in Europe, where they feed on decomposing litter and produce large amounts of faeces16,38,39,40. Detritivores were kept in plastic boxes and fed with moist litter from various tree species from their respective collection sites before the start of the experiment.

To obtain a gradient of leaf litter quality, we collected leaf litter from six deciduous broadleaf tree species in the Scottish Lowlands. These species include sycamore maple (Acer pseudoplatanus, L.), horse chestnut (Aesculus hippocastanum, L.), common hazel (Corylus avellana, L.), European beech (Fagus sylvatica, L.), English oak (Quercus robur, L.) from a woodland near Dundee, UK (56°32′08.5″N, 3°01′51.9″W) and lime (Tilia platyphyllos, L.) from a woodland in Stirling, UK (56°08′29.5″N, 3°55′14.2″W). Because detritivores are most active in spring and summer in these ecosystems, they feed on partially decomposed litter, which they prefer over freshly fallen litter (David and Gillon8). We thus collected leaf litter from the forest floor in May 2018, air-dried it and stored it in cardboard boxes until use.

Faeces production

To compare the quality and decomposability of leaf litter with faeces derived from the same litter and produced by diverse detritivore species, we set up two series of boxes for the production of the needed material. In the first of these series, we placed each detritivore species together with each litter species to produce the 36 different faeces types (Fig. 1; 6 litter species × 6 detritivore species = 36 faeces types). The second of these series contained the litter species only without any detritivores to produce intact litter from each tree species (6 litter species) under the same conditions for the same amount of time. In total, 42 different substrates were generated. To do so, we placed ca. 30 g of air-dry leaf litter from each species separately in plastic boxes (30 cm × 22 cm × 5.5 cm) to which we added ca. 50 individuals from each detritivore species separately or no detritivore for the intact litter treatment. We sprayed the litter with water to optimise litter moisture for detritivore consumption while avoiding water accumulation at the bottom of the boxes. We kept the boxes at room temperature (ca. 20 °C) for 4 weeks and collected the produced faeces/intact litter twice a week. For the faeces, we placed the content of each box in a large bucket and gently agitated to let detritivores and faeces fall to the bottom of the bucket. After collecting the faeces, we placed all the leaf litter and detritivores back into their boxes and sprayed the litter with water to keep moisture conditions constant. For the intact litter treatment, we followed the same procedure but collected just three random leaves out of the buckets. After each collection step, the combination-specific pools of leaf litter and faeces were dried at 30 °C. At the end of the faeces production period, we manually removed small leaf litter fragments from all combination-specific pools of faeces. Additionally, because detritivores feed on leaf lamina and leave leaf veins mostly uneaten6, we cut out the veins from the species-specific pools of intact leaf litter. This was done to ensure the comparability of quality and decomposability between faeces and intact litter.

Litter and faeces quality

To evaluate the effect of litter conversion into detritivore faeces on organic matter quality, we compared the quality of faeces to that of intact litter by measuring a series of physical and chemical quality parameters on all 42 substrates (6 litter species + 36 faeces types). Chemical characteristics included total carbon (C) and nitrogen (N) concentrations, DOC and TDN concentrations, total tannin concentrations, and 13C solid-state NMR spectra. Physical characteristics included WHC and specific area (surface area per unit of mass). Prior to these measurements, we drew three subsamples from each pool of substrate type. A part of each subsample was ground using a ball mill (TissueLyser II, Qiagen) to measure total C, N and tannin concentration and generate NMR spectra. The other part of each subsample was kept intact and used for all other measurements. All measurements were thus done on these three subsamples per substrate type, except for NMR spectra that were measured once per substrate type on a sample made by pooling all three ground subsamples. This pooling was necessary to obtain a sample large enough for the NMR analyses. Total C and N concentrations were measured with a flash CHN elemental analyser (Flash Smart, ThermoScientific). To measure DOC and TDN, we extracted leachates by placing ca. 30 mg of air-dried material with 25 ml of deionised water in 50 ml Falcon tubes and agitating the tubes horizontally on a reciprocal shaker for 1 h. Water extracts were then filtered through 0.45-μm cellulose nitrate filters to isolate the leachate fraction. Concentrations of DOC and TDN in leachates were measured with a TOC analyser (Shimadzu, Kyoto, Japan) equipped with a supplementary module for N. Tannin concentrations were measured with the protein-precipitable phenolics microplate assay, a microplate protocol adapted from Hagerman and Butler41. We obtained 13C-NMR spectra by applying 13C cross-polarisation magic angle spinning NMR spectroscopy using a 200 MHz spectrometer (Bruker, Billerica, USA). The samples were spun in 7 mm zirconium dioxide rotors at 6.8 kHz with an acquisition time of 0.01024 s. To avoid Hartmann–Hahn mismatches, a ramped 1H impulse was applied during a contact time of 1 ms. We applied a delay time of 2.0 s and the number of scans was set to 1500, yet some of the samples required longer measurements due to the low amount of sample material; in this case, we multiplied the number of scans to 3000, 6000 or 15000. As reference for the chemical shift, tetramethylsilane was used (0 ppm). We used the following chemical shift regions to integrate the spectra: −10–45 ppm alkyl C, 45–110 ppm O/N alkyl C, 110–160 ppm aromatic C, and 160–220 ppm carboxylic C. We measured the WHC by placing ca. 15 mg of air-dried intact material with 1.5 ml of deionised water in 2 ml Eppendorf tubes, agitating the tubes horizontally on a reciprocal shaker for 2 h, retrieving the material and placing it on a Whatman filter to remove excess water, weighing the wet material and reweighing it after drying at 65 °C for 48 h. We measured the specific area of leaf litter, faecal pellets and faeces particles from photographs using a stereomicroscope (ZEISS STEMI 508). For leaf litter and faecal pellets, we took photographs of ca. 20 mg of air-dried intact material. To visualise faeces particles, we weighed ca. 1 mg of air-dried faecal pellets and placed them in a beaker with 20 ml of deionised water for 2 h, allowing complete dissolution of the faecal pellets. We then filtered the faeces particles and photographed the filters under a stereomicroscope. Dimensions of each litter pieces and faecal pellets/faeces particles were measured using the image analysis software (ImageJ, version 1.46r). For all substrate types, we divided the calculated surface area by the dry mass of the sample to obtain the specific area.

Faeces and litter decomposition parameters

To evaluate the effect of litter conversion into detritivore faeces on C and N cycling, we compared the C and N loss of faeces to that of intact litter by incubating all 42 substrates in microcosms under controlled conditions for 6 months (180 days). Microcosms consisted of 250-ml plastic containers filled with 90 mg of air-dry soil collected from a temperate grassland (56°8′40.1″N, 3°54′50.9″W). We chose this soil to avoid any home-field advantage effect as this soil did not receive litter input from any of the studied tree species and none of the selected soil animals were present at this site. About 120 mg of each substrate were placed separately within a small polyvinyl chloride tube (30 mm diameter × 30 mm height) closed in the bottom with a 100-µm mesh and left open on the top. Each tube was then placed on top of the soil within the microcosm. Five replicates per substrate were prepared, resulting in a total of 210 microcosms (42 substrates × 5 replicates). Microcosms were watered by adding water directly over the tube containing faeces/litter so as to reach 70% of soil WHC and incubated at 22 °C and 70% relative humidity in a controlled environment chamber. To limit desiccation while ensuring gas exchange, we drilled four 3-mm holes in each microcosm cap. These microcosms were then weighed weekly and watered to their initial weight at 70% soil WHC. We placed replicates on separated shelves according to a randomised complete block design. Both block positions within the controlled environment chamber and microcosm positions within blocks were randomised weekly. After 180 days, remaining intact litter and faeces in microcosms were collected, dried at 30 °C for 48 h, weighed and ground with a ball mill (TissueLyser II, Qiagen). We measured C and N concentrations in all samples with a flash CHN Elemental Analyser (Flash Smart, ThermoScientific). The percentage of C and N lost after the incubation was calculated as:

$$frac{{M_{rm{i}} times {rm{CN}}_{rm{i}} – M_{rm{f}} times {rm{CN}}_{rm{f}}}}{{M_{rm{i}} times {rm{CN}}_{rm{i}}}} times 100,$$

where Mi and Mf are the initial and final 30 °C dry masses, respectively, and CNi and CNf are the initial and final C or N concentrations, respectively.

Statistics and reproducibility

To visualise how the 11 physicochemical characteristics were related and how their values differed between all substrates, we used a PCA, with all variables centred and standardised prior to ordination. Because NMR spectra were measured on a composite sample combining the three replicates of each substrate, a unique value was attributed to all replicates for each NMR region.

To test our first hypothesis, we tested the overall effect of substrate form (faeces vs. intact litter) on quality (scores on PC1 and PC2) and decomposition (C and N losses) of all substrates using Student’s t tests. To identify the faeces types with significantly different quality (scores on PC1 and PC2) and decomposition (C and N losses) compared to that of the intact litter from which the faeces were derived, we tested the effect of substrate identity (all 42 substrates included as individual levels) on quality (scores on PC1 and PC2) and decomposition (C and N losses) using one-way ANOVAs. We then used Tukey’s honestly significant difference tests to determine significant differences between each faeces type and the corresponding intact litter.

To test our second hypothesis, we expressed the changes in quality and decomposition following litter conversion into detritivore faeces as net differences in quality (scores on PC1 and PC2) and decomposition (C and N losses) between faeces and the litter from which faeces were derived. We then compared the hypothesised role of intact litter quality/decomposition (PC1 and PC2 scores, C and N losses) and the role of detritivore species on changes in quality/decomposition (net differences in PC1 and PC2 scores, C and N losses) by performing ANCOVAs with intact litter quality/decomposition as the continuous variable and detritivore species as categorical variable (all six detritivore species as individual levels). For all ANVOCAs, the variance associated with each term (intact litter quality/decomposition; detritivore species; interaction) was computed by dividing the sum of squares by the total sum of squares.

To evaluate the relation between quality parameters (PC1 and PC2 scores) and C and N losses from intact litter and faeces separately, we determined the relations between intact litter and faeces C and N losses and their scores on PC1 and PC2 with simple linear regressions and visualised these relations by fitting these variables as supplementary variables on the PCA.

For all statistical tests on C and N losses, block was included in the model as a random variable. All data were checked for normal distribution and homoscedasticity of residuals. All analyses were performed using the R software (version 3.5.3).

Reporting summary

Further information on research design is available in the Nature Research Reporting Summary linked to this article.


Source: Ecology - nature.com

Rearing substrate impacts growth and macronutrient composition of Hermetia illucens (L.) (Diptera: Stratiomyidae) larvae produced at an industrial scale

Power-free system harnesses evaporation to keep items cool