Winter temperatures predominate in spring phenological responses to warming

IPCC Climate Change 2014: Impacts, Adaptation, and Vulnerability (eds Field, C. B. et al.) (Cambridge Univ. Press, 2014).

Miller-Rushing, A. J. & Primack, R. B. Global warming and flowering times in Thoreau’s Concord: a community perspective. Ecology 89, 332—341 (2008).

Article  Google Scholar 

Menzel, A. et al. European phenological response to climate change matches the warming pattern. Glob. Change Biol. 12, 1969–1976 (2006).

Article  Google Scholar 

Cleland, E. E., Chuine, I., Menzel, A., Mooney, H. A. & Schwartz, M. D. Shifting plant phenology in response to global change. Trends Ecol. Evol. 22, 357–365 (2007).

Article  Google Scholar 

Wolkovich, E. M. et al. Warming experiments underpredict plant phenological responses to climate change. Nature 485, 494–497 (2012).

CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

Rutishauser, T., Luterbacher, J., Defila, C., Frank, D. & Wanner, H. Swiss spring plant phenology 2007: extremes, a multi-century perspective, and changes in temperature sensitivity. Geophys. Res. Lett. 35, L05703 (2008).

Article  Google Scholar 

Yu, H. Y., Luedeling, E. & Xu, J. C. Winter and spring warming result in delayed spring phenology on the Tibetan Plateau. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 107, 22151–22156 (2010).

CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

Wang, X. et al. No trends in spring and autumn phenology during the global warming hiatus. Nat. Commun. 10, 2389 (2019).

Article  CAS  Google Scholar 

Fu, Y. S. H. et al. Declining global warming effects on the phenology of spring leaf unfolding. Nature 526, 104–107 (2015).

CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

Chuine, I. et al. Can phenological models predict tree phenology accurately in the future? The unrevealed hurdle of endodormancy break. Glob. Change Biol. 22, 3444–3460 (2016).

Article  Google Scholar 

Harrington, C. A. & Gould, P. J. Tradeoffs between chilling and forcing in satisfying dormancy requirements for Pacific Northwest tree species. Front. Plant Sci. 6, 120 (2015).

Article  Google Scholar 

Zohner, C. M., Benito, B. M., Svenning, J. C. & Renner, S. S. Day length unlikely to constrain climate-driven shifts in leaf-out times of northern woody plants. Nat. Clim. Change 6, 1120–1123 (2016).

Article  Google Scholar 

Basler, D. & Körner, C. Photoperiod and temperature responses of bud swelling and bud burst in four temperate forest tree species. Tree Physiol. 34, 377–388 (2014).

Article  Google Scholar 

Caffarra, A., Donnelly, A., Chuine, I. & Jones, M. B. Modelling the timing of Betula pubescens bud-burst. I. Temperature and photoperiod: a conceptual model. Clim. Res. 46, 147–157 (2011).

Article  Google Scholar 

Flynn, D. F. B. & Wolkovich, E. M. Temperature and photoperiod drive spring phenology across all species in a temperate forest community. New Phytol. 219, 1353–1362 (2018).

CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

Caffarra, A., Donnelly, A. & Chuine, I. Modelling the timing of Betula pubescens budburst. II. Integrating complex effects of photoperiod into process-based models. Clim. Res. 46, 159–170 (2011).

Article  Google Scholar 

Fraga, H., Pinto, J. G. & Santos, J. A. Climate Change projections for chilling and heat forcing conditions in European vineyards and olive orchards: a multi-model assessment. Climatic Change 152, 179–193 (2019).

Article  Google Scholar 

Heide, O. Daylength and thermal time responses of budburst during dormancy release in some northern deciduous trees. Physiol. Plant. 88, 531–540 (1993).

CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

Singh, R. K., Svystun, T., AlDahmash, B., Jönsson, A. M. & Bhalerao, R. P. Photoperiod- and temperature-mediated control of phenology in trees—a molecular perspective. New Phytol. 213, 511–524 (2017).

CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

Vitasse, Y. & Basler, D. What role for photoperiod in the bud burst phenology of European beech. Eur. J. For. Res. 132, 1–8 (2013).

Article  Google Scholar 

Vitasse, Y. & Basler, D. Is the use of cuttings a good proxy to explore phenological responses of temperate forests in warming and photoperiod experiments? Tree Physiol. 34, 174–183 (2014).

Article  Google Scholar 

Laube, J. et al. Chilling outweighs photoperiod in preventing precocious spring development. Glob. Change Biol. 20, 170–182 (2014).

Article  Google Scholar 

Basler, D. & Körner, C. Photoperiod sensitivity of bud burst in 14 temperate forest tree species. Agric. For. Meteorol. 165, 73–81 (2012).

Article  Google Scholar 

Caffarra, A. & Donnelly, A. The ecological significance of phenology in four different tree species: effects of light and temperature on bud burst. Int. J. Biometeorol. 55, 711–721 (2011).

Article  Google Scholar 

Ohlemüller, R., Gritti, E. S., Sykes, M. T. & Thomas, C. D. Towards European climate risk surfaces: the extent and distribution of analogous and non-analogous climates 1931–2100. Glob. Ecol. Biogeogr. 15, 395–405 (2006).

Article  Google Scholar 

Williams, J. W. & Jackson, S. T. Novel climates, no-analog communities, and ecological surprises. Front. Ecol. Environ. 5, 475–482 (2007).

Article  Google Scholar 

Williams, J. W., Jackson, S. T. & Kutzbacht, J. E. Projected distributions of novel and disappearing climates by 2100 AD. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 104, 5738–5742 (2007).

CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

IPCC Climate Change 2013: The Physical Science Basis (eds Stocker, T. F. et al.) (Cambridge Univ. Press, 2013).

Xu, Y., Ramanathan, V. & Victor, D. G. Global warming will happen faster than we think. Nature 564, 30–32 (2018).

Wolkovich, E. M. et al. Observed Spring Phenology Responses in Experimental Environments (OSPREE) (Knowledge Network for Biocomplexity, 2019); https://doi.org/10.5063/F1CZ35KB

Richardson, E. A model for estimating the completion of rest for ‘Redhaven’ and ’Elberta’ peach trees. HortScience 9, 331–332 (1974).

Google Scholar 

Dennis, F. Problems in standardizing methods for evaluating the chilling requirements for the breaking of dormancy in buds of woody plants. HortScience 38, 347–350 (2003).

Article  Google Scholar 

Gelman, A. & Hill, J. Data Analysis Using Regression and Multilevel/Hierarchical Models (Cambridge Univ. Press, 2006).

Fu, Y. H. et al. Short photoperiod reduces the temperature sensitivity of leaf-out in saplings of Fagus sylvatica but not in horse chestnut. Glob. Change Biol. 25, 1696–1703 (2019).

Article  Google Scholar 

Bradley, N. L., Leopold, A. C., Ross, J. & Huffaker, W. Phenological changes reflect climate change in Wisconsin. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 96, 9701–9704 (1999).

CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

Gauzere, J., Lucas, C., Ronce, O., Davi, H. & Chuine, I. Sensitivity analysis of tree phenology models reveals increasing sensitivity of their predictions to winter chilling temperature and photoperiod with warming climate. Ecol. Model. 441, 108805 (2019).

Article  Google Scholar 

Heide, O. & Prestrud, A. Low temperature, but not photoperiod, controls growth cessation and dormancy induction and release in apple and pear. Tree Physiol. 25, 109–114 (2005).

CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

van der Schoot, C., Paul, L. K. & Rinne, P. L. H. The embryonic shoot: a lifeline through winter. J. Exp. Bot. 65, 1699–1712 (2014).

Article  CAS  Google Scholar 

Fishman, S., Erez, A. & Couvillon, G. The temperature dependence of dormancy breaking in plants: mathematical analysis of a two-step model involving a cooperative transition. J. Theor. Biol. 124, 473–483 (1987).

Article  Google Scholar 

Weinberger, J. H. et al. Chilling requirements of peach varieties. Proc. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 56, 122–128 (1950).

Polgar, C. A., Primack, R. B., Williams, E. H., Stichter, S. & Hitchcock, C. Climate effects on the flight period of Lycaenid butterflies in Massachusetts. Biol. Conserv. 160, 25–31 (2013).

Article  Google Scholar 

Vitasse, Y. Ontogenic changes rather than difference in temperature cause understory trees to leaf out earlier. New Phytol. 198, 149–155 (2013).

Article  Google Scholar 

Laube, J., Sparks, T. H., Estrella, N. & Menzel, A. Does humidity trigger tree phenology? Proposal for an air humidity based framework for bud development in spring. New Phytol. 202, 350–355 (2014).

Article  Google Scholar 

Li, C., Stevens, B. & Marotzke, J. Eurasian winter cooling in the warming hiatus of 1998–2012. Geophys. Res. Lett. 42, 8131–8139 (2015).

Article  Google Scholar 

Balling, R. C. J., Michaels, P. J. & Knappenberger, P. C. Analysis of winter and summer warming rates in gridded temperature time series. Clim. Res. 9, 175–181 (1998).

Article  Google Scholar 

Hänninen, H. Effects of climatic change on trees from cool and temperate regions: an ecophysiological approach to modelling of bud burst phenology. Can. J. Bot. 73, 183–199 (1995).

Article  Google Scholar 

Güsewell, S., Furrer, R., Gehrig, R. & Pietragalla, B. Changes in temperature sensitivity of spring phenology with recent climate warming in Switzerland are related to shifts of the preseason. Glob. Change Biol.23, 5189–5202 (2017).

Article  Google Scholar 

Roberts, A. M., Tansey, C., Smithers, R. J. & Phillimore, A. B. Predicting a change in the order of spring phenology in temperate forests. Glob. Change Biol.21, 2603–2611 (2015).

Article  Google Scholar 

Moher, D., Liberati, A., Tetzlaff, J. & Altman, D. G. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. Ann. Intern. Med. 151, 264–269 (2009).

Article  Google Scholar 

Kicinski, M. Publication bias in recent meta-analyses. PLoS ONE 8, e81823 (2013).

Gurevitch, J., Morrow, L. L., Wallace, A. & Walsh, J. S. A meta-analysis of competition in field experiments. Am. Nat. 140, 539–572 (1992).

Article  Google Scholar 

Gurevitch, J. & Hedges, L. V. Statistical issues in ecological meta-analyses. Ecology 80, 1142–1149 (1999).

Article  Google Scholar 

Lin, L. F. & Chu, H. T. Quantifying publication bias in meta-analysis. Biometrics 74, 785–794 (2018).

Article  Google Scholar 

Luedeling, E. & Brown, P. H. A global analysis of the comparability of winter chill models for fruit and nut trees. Int. J. Biometeorol. 55, 411–421 (2011).

Article  Google Scholar 

R Core Team R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing (R Foundation for Statistical Computing, 2017).

Luedeling, E. chillR: statistical methods for phenology analysis in temperate fruit trees. R package version 0.70.17 (2019).

Cornes, R. C., van der Schrier, G., van den Besselaar, E. J. & Jones, P. D. An ensemble version of the E-OBS temperature and precipitation data sets. J. Geophys. Res. Atmos. 123, 9391–9409 (2018).

Article  Google Scholar 

Livneh, B.et al. A spatially comprehensive, hydrometeorological data set for Mexico, the US, and Southern Canada 1950–2013. Sci. Data 2, 150042 (2015).

Harrington, C. A., Gould, P. J. & St Clair, J. B. Modeling the effects of winter environment on dormancy release of Douglas-fir. For. Ecol. Manag. 259, 798–808 (2010).

Article  Google Scholar 

Carpenter, B. et al. Stan: a probabilistic programming language. J. Stat. Softw. https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v076.i01(2017).

Stan Development Team. RStan: the R interface to Stan. R package version 2.17.3 (2018).

Gelman, A. et al. Bayesian Data Analysis (CRC Press, 2014).

Gauzere, J. et al. Integrating interactive effects of chilling and photoperiod in phenological process-based models. A case study with two European tree species: Fagus sylvatica and Quercus petraea. Agric. For. Meteorol. 244, 9–20 (2017).

Article  Google Scholar 

Saikkonen, K. et al. Climate change-driven species’ range shifts filtered by photoperiodism. Nat. Clim. Change 2, 239 (2012).

Article  Google Scholar 

Way, D. A. & Montgomery, R. A. Photoperiod constraints on tree phenology, performance and migration in a warming world. Plant Cell Environ. 38, 1725–1736 (2015).

Article  Google Scholar 

Chuine, I., Garcia de Cortazar Atauri, I., Hanninen, H. & Kramer, K. in Phenology: An Integrative Environmental Science (ed. Schwartz M.) 275–293 (Springer, 2013).

Stan Development Team Stan User’s Guide v.2.19 (Stan, 2019).